The Story

I'm using Amazon's EC2 for some of my VMs, which run CentOS. When viewing Block Device Mappings (mapping between the virtual storage - ebs, ephemerals etc. and the block devices inside the VM) in CentOS 6.5, I ran into an annoying issue. When inspecting my instance metadata using:


My ephemeral drive shows up as sdb.
However, when viewing my actual devices, I found it became sdf:

ls -l /dev/sd*
lrwxrwxrwx. 1 root root 4 2014-12-10 13:09 /dev/sda -> xvde
lrwxrwxrwx. 1 root root 4 2014-12-10 13:09 /dev/sdf -> xvdf
lrwxrwxrwx. 1 root root 4 2014-12-10 13:09 /dev/sdg -> xvdg

This means I can't rely on the mappings for my scripts, meaning I can't easily differentiate between ephemeral drives (fast, free and get wiped every time the instance stops) and EBS drives. Pretty problematic.

Red herrings

I found a udev rule in /etc/udev/rules.d/99-ami-udev.rules, which looked like

KERNEL=="xvd*", PROGRAM="/usr/sbin/ami-udev %k", SYMLINK+="%c"

Which led me to /usr/sbin/ami-udev

if [ "$#" -ne 1 ] ; then
  echo "$0 <device>" >&2
  exit 1
  if echo "$1"|grep -qE 'xvd[a-z][0-9]?' ; then
    echo sd$( echo ${1:3:1} | sed "y/[e-v]/[a-z]/" )${1:4:2}
    echo "$1"

which led me to read about seds "transliteration".

All for nothing, because the problem wasn't there

The true issue

For reasons I don't completely understand (I'm sure they're valid, I just don't understand them), RHEL guys decided to change xen_blkfront, the module in charge of loading virtualized Xen hard drives.
This Bugzilla entry points out the issue - virtual SCSI devices (which is what Amazon is using) are now starting at "e", meaning the first device is xvde (rather than xvda).

While not an issue by itself, Amazon's metadata service is unaware of this change, causing the metadata to disagree with the real data.

The road I didn't take

The first solution that I tried is to modify the parameter mentioned in the entry (sda_is_xvda) to cause the kernel to start naming the devices in the "right" order.
This method has the following steps:

  • Make sure nothing depends on the current block device names
  • Add an entry to modprobe to change the parameter sda_is_xvda to 1.
    I did it using

    echo options xen_blkfront sda_is_xvda=1 | sudo tee /etc/modprobe.d/xen_blkfront.conf
  • Rebuild the kernel image (since this is part of the image)

    sudo dracut -f
  • Reboot and check for modified drives

I chose not to do this because I didn't want to customize my kernel if I didn't have to, not to mention mandating a reboot before continuing my setup.

The road I took

While less elegant, I've decided to compensate for RHEL's nonsense in my scripts.
It's not that complicated (echo sdb | perl -p -e 'substr($_,2,1)=~tr{a-j}{e-p}' prints sdf), but I needed a way to make sure the server has this "xvde is the first iscsi device" configuration before compensating for it.
My solution to this issue was to compare this (root drive as seen by AWS):

r=$(curl -s
echo ${r: -2:1}

to this (root drive IRL):

mount | perl -nae 'print substr($F[0],-1),"\n" if / on \/ /;'

If these results are different, that means that AWS and our OS aren't seeing eye-to-eye, and we need to compensate.

Bonus - Chef test

This is my real implementation in Chef:

real_root=`mount`.split("\n").select{ |i| i[/ on \/ /]}.first[/^([^ ]+[a-zA-Z])\d? /,1][-1,1]
block_diff=(aws_root == real_root) ? nil : real_root[0].ord - aws_root[0].ord